International Labor Schemes

By Rex Alex

Changing gender attitudes through seasonal work

The labor schemes promoted by Australia and New Zealand offer a solution to the conflicts faced by Environmental Refugees. For example, New Zealand and Australia have opened seasonal workers programs for Pacific Islanders. Australia has also opened nursing programs through the Kiribati Australia Nursing Initiative and invested in the Kiribati Institute of Technology in which students will be educated with Australian standards. Such programs offer the chance for eventual permanent settlement  and social mobility for Pacific Islanders. While such opportunities can be helpful, they also come with the risk of labor exploitation, particularly for seasonal fruit picking workers. Another concern with these programs is how they are operated exclusively within the standards of the country which funds them. This can cause the  Pacific Island nations to lose sovereignty and the Indigenous people of these islands may lose their culture and knowledge regarding the land. Furthermore these programs are critiqued for disproportionately benefiting young, educated and upper-class Kiribati, who are only a small percentage.  

 

Klepp, Silja, and Johannes Herbeck. “The Politics of Environmental Migration and Climate Justice in the Pacific Region.” Journal of Human Rights and the Environment, vol. 7, no. 1, Mar. 2016, pp. 54–73, 10.4337/jhre.2016.01.03. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Silja-Klepp-2/publication/299575803_The_politics_of_environmental_migration_and_climate_justice_in_the_Pacific_region/links/5852859708aef7d030a4eaa9/The-politics-of-environmental-migration-and-climate-justice-in-the-Pacific-region.pdf  

Migration With Dignity

By Rex Alex

He leads the country that could drown | Fortune

There are several innovative policy solutions which are being implemented in hopes to remediate current climate conflicts and avoid future complications, however such policies are not without unique shortcomings. One such policy is the “Migration with Dignity” initiative which was implemented by Kiribati President Anote Tong. As a nation of small islands and atolls, Kiribati has no sustainable internal migration solution; thus the goal is to develop large expatriate communities in Australia, New Zealand and other developed nations which comes with the additional benefit of remittances for Kiribati. Furthermore, the core policy is to “upskill” Kiribati citizens through government programs which provide education or job training so that they can migrate to new countries not as victims but as qualified workers. While the intent of this policy is noble, it fails to reach those with limited literacy and subsistence livelihoods. Also, Many people view the ‘migrate with dignity’ strategy critically, as it reinforces the image of Kiribati as a ‘climate change poster child’ and symbolic “sinking island state”, such stereotypes are rejected by Kiribati citizens.  

McNamara, Karen. “Cross-Border Migration with Dignity in Kiribati.” Researchgate.net, May 2015,  https://www.fmreview.org/sites/fmr/files/FMRdownloads/en/climatechange-disasters/mcnamara.pdf