Star Trek is an unusual series for me to watch, as someone who is fascinated by space epics and grew up hearing about it constantly. And during my time in this class I’ve come to learn that the series just… doesn’t capture me in the way I thought it would ! I feel bad about it, but I don’t think it’s my thing. I mean maybe deep down fantasy and horror are my genres and sci-fi is just the cool popular kid I want to be like. But I digress. I think Data may have changed my mind about the series.
I have always loved the concept of androids in media. My favorite video game, Persona 3, has an android character named Aigis. I remember playing the game for the first time in middle school and being shaken to my core as she said “I want to live.” It took me some time to fully understand what this statement meant. Of course, she already appeared to be alive. But I think she was referring to living rather than the state of being alive. Making memories and really feeling. I thought about this when I watched The Measure of a Man, particularly when Data talked about what made memories unique. While androids are often depicted as emotionless machines, Data expresses his deep need for emotions in order to recall memories for what they are and experience them properly. While Maddox seemed to disagree with the importance of giving machines humanlike emotions, Data is displaying here the importance of emotions in recalling memories. Much like in Inside Out, memories can be experienced different ways depending on the emotions felt at the time. Without the ability to feel, Data would recall facts and nothing else. Sometimes, that isn’t enough.
Marjorie Prime reminded me a bit of a game of telephone. At the start, you have the real story of how Walter proposed to Marjorie. However, at her request, Walter Prime changes the story to meet her romanticized version of the life she no longer remembers. When Marjorie passes, this altered story is passed on to Marjorie Prime and, later, Tess Prime as well. These AI versions of this family are likely far removed from the real versions of Walter, Marjorie, and Tess. Aside from the altered proposal story, requested by Marjorie, we have the story of the flags she recalled, which were a scene from a movie and not an experience she and Walter ever had. But because the Primes are told this is true, it has now become true. I wonder if we can call this a version of the Mandela Effect. Collectively, they believe in an altered version of the truth. Though, it’s because they were told an altered version of it.
Though, if I’m being perfectly honest, the best part of the movie was when Jon was holding the shiba puppy. I couldn’t focus on anything else in that scene the dog was so damn cute I couldn’t handle it. The movie had a great concept, though I feel the execution could have been a bit stronger. Regardless, it was worth the watch if only for the cutest dog I have ever seen.
I told my dad about Marjorie Prime and he said it bore a resemblance to the Black Mirror episode titled “Be Right Back.” Now, I don’t have any intention on watching Black Mirror, but if anyone is a fan of the series or curious about it, it might be beneficial to take a look !