Blog Post Two.

Back in 2012,  a clip of the opening scene of HBO’s “The Newsroom” began circulating on the Internet. The 6-minute scene portrays what seems to be a panel discussion. A group of college students have the chance to ask the panelists questions regarding politics. The first couple of students ask simple questions that receive vague and repetitive answers. When a young women approaches, she poses the question, is America the greatest country in the world? The next couple of minutes takes the audience on a roller coaster of emotions as one panelist gives his honest answer. This has been a question that has caused controversy among the public, as there are seemingly two distinct sides. Either yes, you think it’s the greatest country in the world, or you don’t. This clip immediately came into my mind, as I remember that despite being only 12, it made me being to question the question itself (even though I had never seen the actual show).  The clip was aired roughly 6 years ago, and is still very much relevant now. I choose this clip, as it ignites conversation about topics that we are uncomfortable talking about, which is something we are seeing so blatantly in these times. It is important to analyze this scene, as it’s main focus seems to be trying to get the audience to question and inform themselves about the state of our country and the injustices that occurred and still occur. It also provokes the discussion of questions posed today such as, has America ever been a great country? What exactly constitutes it being a great country? I think this clip has a lot of substance, and is really thought provoking.

 

One thought on “Blog Post Two.

  1. Hi Daniela,

    Thanks for your post. I think this is a neat “text” to analyze. I’ve heard of this show but I haven’t seen it. The writer, Aaron Sorkin, also wrote the show The West Wing, which was an extremely popular and well-written political show.

    I think you are right about the “exigency” behind this piece, since our current president’s big slogan is always that he promises to “make America great again,” which of course has sparked many of the questions that you bring up in this post. This certainly will be a relevant piece to take a look at. As you move forward, make sure you focus not necessarily on the “issue” itself, but on how well (or not) this scene communicates the argument you believe its trying to make. So the first step will be to get really clear on what exactly you think Sorkin wants this clip to demonstrate, and then analyze how you think he’s successful in doing so.

    Good job so far. I look forward to reading more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *