Gender Issues and the Law

This course is taught under the assumption that most of the students attending this course do not intend to enter law schools or the employment of an in agency after their graduation. They take Gender Issues in the Law  because it is an alternative to fulfil the necessary credits or they believe it is something different. This course is therefore designed to provide an overview of the status of gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender Americans today.

This course engages students directly with important decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court and other courts to trace the development of rights pertaining to sexual orientation and identity, evolution of the right to privacy, regulation of parenthood, marriage and family; freedom of speech and expression;  and the US Military. The course emphasizes the important interface between law and the democratic political process in expanding the equality of the LGBT community.

ParT I: course InformaTIon
This course is taught under the assumption that most of the students attending
this course do not intend to enter law schools or the employment of a
regulatory agency after their graduation. They take Gender Issues in the Law
because it is an alternative to fulfil the necessary credits or they believe it is
something different. This course is therefore designed to provide an overview
of the status of gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender Americans today. This
course engages students directly with important decisions of the U.S. Supreme
Court and other courts to trace the development of rights pertaining to sexual
orientation and identity, evolution of the right to privacy, regulation of
parenthood, marriage, and family; freedom of speech and expression; and the
US Military. The course emphasizes the important interface between law and
the democratic political process in expanding the equality of the LGBTQ
community.

There will be three major parts to the course:

PART I. UNDERSTANDING SYSTEMIC ELEMENTS OF US LAW

PART II. ENGAGING IN LEGAL AND POLITICAL ISSUES ANALYSES

PART III. PROJECTS AND PRESENTATIONS

As with all introductory college courses, a word of caution is required. This
course presents an overview of the relevant federal and state laws and major
legal decisions pertaining to discrimination against the LGBTQ community. It
is not intended to provide a comprehensive analysis of those laws. Case
citations are provided but the citations are not exhaustive as might occur with
a Treatise. With a few exceptions, there is little discussion of policy issues,
although the relevant statutes, regulations and case law are often placed in
historical perspective for clarity.

Page3
The topic of the rights of lesbians, gay men, bisexuals, and trans and non
binary individuals (“LGBTQ”) is very broad and could include a nearly endless
list of topics. This course will focus on the topics that are unique to the LGBTQ
community rather than focus on the topic of “gender” broadly as it applies to
these communities and others. In other words, this is not an indepth course
on the broad topics of sex or gender discrimination. The topics included in this
course include regulation of sexuality, regulation of gender/appearance,
regulation of marriage and family, the United States military, federal state and
local nondiscrimination statutes and ordinances, First Amendment case law,
and religious freedom. But these topics are only covered as they relate to the
LGBTQ community.

This topic is very dynamic as reflected in the significant changes that have
occurred since 2015. Our textbook is not intended to serve as a substitute for
thorough analysis and examination of the very complex legal rules at issue. It
should be used as guidance only, for a very broad background of the subject
matter. Students are encouraged to supplement this textbook with research on
the current legal rules.

ParT II: course LearnInG objecTIves and
assessmenTs

SBC Learning Objectives & Outcomes

This course aims to:

provide you with fundamental knowledge of the US legal system, its basic
functions and workings, and its most pressing challenges these days that are unique to
the LGBTQ community;

engender a deeper understanding and appreciation of the US legal system, as
well as familiarizing you with its significance for the development of Federal and State
laws as well as politics;

engage on topics of contemporary and timeless significance; and enhance
your analytical skills and your ability to critically engage with gender issues.

the methodology for this material is the analysis of judicial decisions of the
Supreme Court of the United States, federal and state courts, as well as statutory and
constitutional interpretation.

At the end of this course, you will have a deeper understanding of
the multitude of factors that affect the evolution of the judicial

Page4
doctrine, from a historical, political, and legal standpoint and
you will not only learn the subject material but will also develop
skills to become comfortable reading and analyzing court
decisions.

TEXTBOOKS

Primary Resource:

Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity, and the Law in a Nutshell by
Ruth Colker #9781634608992

Additional cases, articles and published materials posted on the D2L

Additional optional reading materials:

Sexual Orientation and Identity: Political and Legal Analysis by

Shannon Gilreath and Lydia E. Lavelle #9781634603584

Women and the Law Stories by Elizabeth M. Schneider | Stephanie
M. Wildman

ISBN: 978159941589

ParT III: course scHeduLe

All page assignments below are in Sexual Orientation, Gender
Identity, and the Law in a Nutshell by Ruth Colker textbook.
Additional readings are provided in hard copies and as links to the
relevant material that can be accessed online.

course ouTLIne

Week 1

Lectures 1 & 2 (Jan 27) (Jan 29)

PDF: The US Legal System and Sources of Law and materials on
D2L Student Questionnaires are due

Page5
Week 2

Lectures 3 & 4 (Feb 3 ) (Feb 5)

Historical Background Due Process and Right to Privacy and
materials on D2L; In re the Matter of Thomas T. BEATIE case, Group
signup and group resume due

Week 3

Lectures 5 & 6 (Feb 10) (Feb12)

Textbook, Chapter 2 Regulation of Sexuality pp. 539 and materials
on D2L; Lawrence v. Texas | 539 U.S. 558 (2003); Roe v. Wade,
410 U.S. 113 (1973);

Dobbs v Jackson women’s health organization 597 us ___ 2022

https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/191392_6j37.pdf

Washington v. Glucksberg | 521 U.S. 702 (1997) extra credit

Week 4

Lectures 7 & 8 (Feb 17) (Feb 19)

Textbook, Chapter 3 Regulation of Gender Identity and Expression
pp. 39100 and materials on D2L; Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins |
490 U.S. 228 (1989); Titlt VII; EEOC

Gavin Grimm case: https://www.aclu.org/cases/grimmv
gloucestercountyschoolboard

Week 5

Lectures 9 & 10 (Feb 24) (Feb 26)

Textbook, Chapter 4 Regulation of Parenthood pp. 101164 and materials
on D2L; Baby M, 537 A.2d 1227, 109 NJ 396 (NJ 1988); Surrogacy;
Uniform Parentage Act; Adoptions Group Process Assessment form is due

Page6
Week 6

Lectures 11 & 12 (March 3) (March 5)

Textbook, Chapter 5 Regulation of Marriage pp. 165206
and materials on D2L;

Obergefell v. Hodges | 576 U.S. 644 (2015) United States v.
Windsor, 570 U.S. 744 (2013 DOMA

Week 7

Lectures 13 & 14 (March 1o) (March 12)

Review; Projects Primer, groups and requirements and materials
on D2L; Group Process Evaluation Form is due

Week 8

Spring Recess: March 1723. No classes in session.
Classes will resume on Monday, March 24th.

Week 9

Lectures 15 & 16 (March 24) (March 26)

Textbook, Chapter 6 Untied States Military pp. 297232 and
materials on D2L Frontiero v. Richardson | 411 U.S. 677 (1973);
DOD Policies Group Process Peer Evaluation Form is due

Week 10

Lectures 17 & 18 (March 31) (Apr 2)

Textbook, Chapter 7 Federal, State and Local Nondiscrimination
laws pp. 233294 and materials on D2L; NY State and NY City
Human Rights; Bostock v. Clayton County, 590 U.S. 644 (2020)
Group Process Assessment form is due

Week 11

Lectures 19 & 20 (Apr 7) (Apr 9)

Textbook, Chapter 8 Freedom of Expression and Association pp.
295 334 and materials on D2L Tinker v. Des Moines
Independent Community School District, 393 U.S. 503 (1969);

Page7
Martinez v. Court of Appeal of California, 528 U.S. 152 (2000);
Equal Access Act

Week 12

Lectures 19 & 20 (Apr 14) (Apr 16)

Textbook, Chapter 9 Religious Freedom pp. 335266 and materials
on D2L; Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., 573 U.S. 682 (2014),

Week 13

Lectures 21 & 22 (Apr 21) (Apr 23)

Review, and Presentation of Projects

Week 14

Lectures 23 & 24 (Apr 28) (Apr 30)

Presentation of Projects

Week 15

Lectures 25 & 26 (May 5) (May 7